Thursday, February 13, 2003
OmbudsGod cites with approval Michael Fumento's takedown of the low-carb Atkins Diet and science writer Gary Taubes. Apparently Fumento has published another attack in Reason; I blogged on this last month when Fumento was published in Reason Online. I haven't read all of the new Reason piece, which is dated March, but it opens with researchers saying they feel unwittingly drafted into supporting the diet when they don't; one describes Taubes as a "dangerous man." Yikes.
The diet works for me. I see this line in the new Reason piece:
In Dr. Atkins' New Diet Revolution, Robert Atkins claims that by simply minimizing your carbohydrate intake you can quickly lose massive amounts of weight, even while pigging out daily on fatback, pork rinds, and lard. He also claims his diet will relieve "fatigue, irritability, depression, trouble concentrating, headaches, insomnia, dizziness, joint and muscle aches, heartburn, colitis, premenstrual syndrome, and water retention and bloating."
Claims like those should make anyone suspicious, even those who have barely scraped through high school biology
Be suspicious all you want. I have minimized by daily carbohydrate intake and I have lost weight even while pigging out on fatback, pork rinds, and lard. Okay, not fatback (what's that?) and lard. But pork rinds, sure, and eggs, bacon, meats of all kinds (chicken, pork, steak, sausage, etc.) as well as fish. I eat all I want. I lost weight and kept it off. And unlike my high-carb days, I never feel bloated or even dizzy after eating a big meal. I feel alert, just like Atkins said I would. It works, folks. Maybe not on everybody, but I gotta tell you I laugh out loud every time I listen to a doctor telling me how it doesn't work.