postwatcher04 - at - hotmail.com

About PostWatch
 
..::Archives::..


 
..::Links::..
The Nation

Winds of Change

Memri

Virginia Gun Rights

= WatchBlogs =
Timeswatch

Alphecca

Biased BBC

ChronWatch (SF Chronicle)

Croooow Blog

OmbudsGod

Regnum Crucis

Rhetorica









  ..::Other Links::..
Debka.com

Independent Women's Forum

Inkwell

MRC

Romanesko

CampusWatch.org

Amy Wellborn

Mark Shea

Kesher Talk

Right Wing News

Eleven Day Empire

Discriminations

Where is Raed?

Healing Iraq

The Command Post

Powerline







 
PostWatch: An irregular correction to the Washington Post


Brought to you by Christopher Rake
















PostWatch
 

Monday, October 28, 2002
 
5:47 PM

Not that great a shot.... a John McCarthy from Florida Today writes to MediaNews.org's letters section:

Bad sniper speculations didn't end with the capture of the two suspects. Nearly every lead I read mentioned Muhammad's marksmanship badge and military service as a Gulf War vet. I can only guess they put this info in the lead because they deemed it an important part of the story.

In reality, though, the marksmanship badge is a very low-level award given to recruits who perform well in basic marksmanship training, which every recruit takes during Basic Military Training. To refer to him as a "sharpshooter," as the Washington Post did repeatedly, is a stretch. Did the Army teach him to shoot a rifle and shoot it well? Absolutely. But it doesn't appear he had any more than the same basic marksmanship training millions of other veterans had. And since Muhammad was a combat engineer, it is very unlikely he saw any combat in the Gulf. As a matter of fact, he probably didn't handle a weapon very often after Basic, other than for annual qualifying.


Gotta say the Post hasn't struck me as misleading on this issue, unless I missed one big story where they hyped it. There have been a few references to Muhammad as a "sharpshooter," but this seemed pretty generic to me and not hyping his abilities--which some other outlets definitely have been guilty of. This Post story even gives some room to downplay his abilities:

He was a mediocre soldier who was once convicted of striking a sergeant in the head, and he wasn't "anything special" as a marksman, according to a former platoon leader.





Comments: Post a Comment
 
Powered by Blogger Pro™


Google
Search WWW Search postwatch.blogspot.com